Election 2004

When NYT headlines go bad

A story in the New York Times with a really bad headline has some really good news for the John Kerry campaign. The headline says: "Both Parties See a Big Increase in New Voters."

Yet directly underneath, the story begins: "A sweeping voter registration campaign in heavily Democratic areas has added tens of thousands of new voters to the rolls in the swing states of Ohio and Florida, a surge that has far exceeded the efforts of Republicans in both states, a review of registration data shows."

With the polls still showing a close race -- maybe a dead heat, maybe a small Bush lead -- it's becoming more and more likely the voter turnout will decide the race. Taking that further, voter registration is the key. Both sides are spending tens of millions on getting their "people" to the polls. And voter registration could also confound the already befuddled pollsters, since new voters are not going to be counted as likely voters.

So....under that unfortunate "fair and balanced" heading, the NYT story by Ford Fessenden (a former colleague we have a lot of respect for) then goes on to show how in two of the three most critical states, Ohio and Florida, it's really just the Democrats seeing the "big increase."

To wit:

"The analysis by The New York Times of county-by-county data shows that in Democratic areas of Ohio - primarily low-income and minority neighborhoods - new registrations since January have risen 250 percent over the same period in 2000. In comparison, new registrations have increased just 25 percent in Republican areas."

"A similar pattern is apparent in Florida: in the strongest Democratic areas, the pace of new registration is 60 percent higher than in 2000, while it has risen just 12 percent in the heaviest Republican areas."

It that truly holds, then (warning: only diehard Philadelphia Phillies fans will get this allusion): "Put those states in the win column for the fightin' Dems."

If you want to discuss the New York Times' headline writing approach with their public editor, Daniel Okrent, his email address is: public@nytimes.com.

UPDATE: The initial headline that appeared on the early, online version was changed slightly for the print edition. It now reads: "A Big Increase of New Voters in Swing States." Unlike the first headline, it's technically accurate -- but still hides the actual point of the story, which is Democrats outregistering Republicans. Is this the "CBS Syndrome," or just lousy headline writing?


Posted on September 25, 2004 02:28 PM
Comments

Was in Ohio that the Dems were registering dead people to vote?

The question that comes to mind, after the 2000 exection, is will the new voters know how to vote?

Posted by: Ted at September 25, 2004 06:00 PM

Looks like *somebody* knows how to execute the good ol' tap-dance talking point of a "false hypothesis" question. hehehe Doesn't look like he knows quite as much about the real facts behind the 2000 election, though; pity -- you used to have to have your facts right before being right*eous*.

Posted by: bill at September 25, 2004 08:10 PM

No Ted. Dems aren't registring dead people in Ohio. But then the GOP doesn't think of registering me in Minnesota. I must look like I'm only half full.

Posted by: wtmpls at September 25, 2004 08:22 PM

I am one of the people they talk about in the article.

I have been registering people in the Orlando, FL area since May.

I have personally registered over 1200 people. My office has registered over 20,000.

The reason I took this job was because of the 2000 election. I was working in the polls, which I usually do. For the first time, I saw voters turned away from the polls, not allowed to vote. Then, I found out that tens of thousands of people in Florida were not allowed to vote. Worse yet, in districts with high minority populations, thousands of votes were simply thrown away.

Believe me, it had NOTHING to do with whether or not people were smart enough to vote or ballot configuration and everything to do with voter fraud.

I was ashamed of my state and my country.

And it's still going on.

Jeb Bush and Katherine Harris made sure to steal the last election and Jeb Bush and Glenda Hood are on track to try and do it again.

So, I get up every day and register more people.

And I am determined to get as many of them out to vote as I can.

Posted by: roooth at September 25, 2004 10:41 PM

Way to go, Roooth! Thanks for all your efforts in Florida. What Jeb and Glenda have been doing is disgraceful.

Posted by: frsbdg at September 26, 2004 03:00 AM

Keep up the good work, Rooth!

Posted by: Barret Skadis at September 26, 2004 03:25 AM

Thanks, Any attempt to shake out the truth, especially in the era when corporate,state and media attempt to make things appear as they are not. Yes, this includes the NYT.

Let me paraphase a passage from Tennyson's memoriam: Oh for a touch of the vanishing truth, And the sound of a voice that has been stilled!

Regards,


Jim Lyle

Posted by: jim lyle at September 26, 2004 08:06 AM

Yes, good for you, Ruth. Keep it up!

Posted by: Ruth at September 26, 2004 08:39 AM

Roooth rote ;] :

[...] I found out that tens of thousands of people in Florida were not allowed to vote. Worse yet, in districts with high minority populations, thousands of votes were simply thrown away.


What I want to know is WHY is the media not SCREAMING THIS from the rooftops??

If they are allowed to get away with this again, then Democracy has truly fallen to the NeoConservatives.

Posted by: Mighty Mike at September 26, 2004 10:31 AM

Hey, if the headline screamed that the Dems registered way more voters, it might rally the Repugnicans to increase their efforts, as reading the story certainly will. Best case, the Repugnicans assume they're going to win so they stay home.

Posted by: vicky at September 26, 2004 11:51 AM

If the Bushies can plant stories showing them in the lead in a state like Ohio,then it's over. I'm not doubting the gist of your story. It's probably right. But if the final polls in Ohio show Bush with the edge,then how hard will it be for someone to switch some votes from Kerry's column to the Bush column since they are using Diebold's paperless touch sreens to vote on.If the final vote agrees with the last polls that showed Bush with the lead then the Dems demanding a recount will be dismissed as whining. It's an electronic contingency plan that insures the desired result for Bush,if he needs it.

Posted by: robert at September 26, 2004 01:04 PM

Why in the world would Ohio vote republican ??
If all the voters in Cleveland that are in poverty the state would go to Kerry...
The polls are manipulated and distorted..
How many of you have been called for a poll ??

Posted by: ron at September 26, 2004 01:22 PM

If you were registering Republicans to vote how could you tell if they were dead or not?
MLL
Atlanta

Posted by: Michael Leo Lively at September 26, 2004 01:56 PM

a vote for kerry is a vote for the terrorists.
plain and simple
jhc

Posted by: John Chandler at September 26, 2004 06:22 PM

I love it. The Democrats are swearing the Republicans stole Florida and are vowing to prevent it happen again. The Republican motto is, "If it's not close, they can't cheat." They're talking about the Democrats, of course.

Aside from wondering what a Marian would conclude about the situation, how does one prevent voter fraud from either side? Our democratic system only works if the votes are clean.

I recall reading a couple of years ago that two states, Alaska and Maine had more people vote than were registered to vote. My memory is a bit fuzzy on this, so I could have the states wrong. But if it is true, that’s worrisome.

I ask again, how do we prevent voter fraud?

Posted by: Ted at September 26, 2004 07:36 PM

Rather than look for bias, note that the NYT article was a Sunday article that was posted online a day early, where a junior copyeditor gave it an incorrect title. Saturdays are the low point of journalism, despite the fact that news happens all week. It has since been corrected.

I have no idea what John Chandler is talking about. There are far more people who will resort to terrorism thanks to the Bush administration's myopic foreign policy than there were targeting the US four years ago. Bomb thy neighbor?

And roooth, I thank you for your efforts. We all win when more people turn out to vote, regardless of party affiliation.

Posted by: Windy at September 26, 2004 09:59 PM

Poor people who vote Republican usually vote by "faith", ie. despite what their eyes tell them, they choose not to believe what they see but what they have been TOLD to believe. Like the person who says that "a vote for Kerry is a vote for terrorists". And under whose watch did 9/11 happen? And who diverted resources from the search for al Queda in Afghanistan to fulfill the neocon's dream of oil domination under the guise of an "imminent" threat from Iraq. And speaking of Iraq, if Repugs believe that Hussein was responsible why is he not being interrogated and charged for the crime since we now have him in custody??? Puh-lezzzz.... you guys don't really believe all those lies, you just want as many gullible fools to believe so you guys can win and while the Religious Right put their rubber stamping judges in our courts to dismantle the rights of women and minorites, the Corporate Right can dismantle environmental and labor protections... ah how you people "love" America! Nope, any fool can see that a vote for Bush is a vote for terrorists... now that he has made Iraq a breeding ground for new terrorists and a poster child for Osama bin Laden's campaign of why Americans should be hated and reviled by the world's one billion Muslims. After all, isn't "kill their leaders and convert the Muslims to Christianity", the Rightwing rallying cry?

Posted by: Jon at September 26, 2004 10:59 PM

Maybe NYT wanted to play down the large Dem lead in getting new voters. Like someone said the best scenario is Repuglican (I love that intentional malaprop) overconfidence, and maybe we should let this one slide, shhhhh, the repugs are ahead (yeah, thats the ticket, shhhhh)

Posted by: Tim at September 27, 2004 01:48 AM

Read Gallup Polls- Conditioning for Vote Rigging http://www.DemocraticTalkRadio.com/demvoices-04-polls_vote_rigging.html for my take on polls and vote rigging. Only a huge voter turn-out can preserve the real democratic winner from vote fraud. I believe this will happen.

Posted by: Stephen Crockett at September 27, 2004 02:58 PM

Sorry wrong URL
http://www.DemocraticTalkRadio.com/demvoices-04-polls_rigged_voting.html

Posted by: Stephen Crockett at September 27, 2004 03:02 PM

Try asking where a lot of this polling data comes from,..... specifically. So much you hear on polls & otherwise nowadays is merely the merest of arrogant unsubstantiations.

Posted by: S. Newhouse at September 27, 2004 04:32 PM

As Harry Truman once said,"any working man who votes republican is a damn fool"

Posted by: marie miller at October 7, 2004 06:02 PM

Nice site. You are doing a great service to the web.

casino online

Posted by: casino online at February 10, 2005 01:49 AM

Very nice site. Keep up the good work.

casino en ligne

Posted by: casino en ligne at February 10, 2005 01:49 AM

You are invited to visit some information about Online Poker Online Poker http://www.nutzu.com/poker.html Texas hold em Texas hold em http://www.nutzu.com/texas-holdem.html Online texas holdem poker Online texas holdem poker http://www.nutzu.com/online-poker.html Partypoker Partypoker http://www.nutzu.com/party-poker.html Pacificpoker Pacificpoker http://www.nutzu.com/pacific-poker.html Empirepoker Empirepoker http://www.nutzu.com/empire-poker.html Texas hold`em Texas hold`em http://www.nutzu.com/texas-hold-em.html online poker online poker http://www.nutzu.com/ Internet poker Internet poker http://www.nutzu.com/internet-poker.html Poker game Poker game http://www.nutzu.com/poker-game.html Texas hold em poker Texas hold em poker http://www.nutzu.com/texas-hold-em-poker.html Online poker games Online poker games http://www.nutzu.com/online-poker-games.html Poker tournament Poker tournament http://www.nutzu.com/poker-tournament.html Poker rules Poker rules http://www.nutzu.com/poker-rules.html Poker hands Poker hands http://www.nutzu.com/poker-hands.html Texas holdem rules Texas holdem rules http://www.nutzu.com/texas-holdem-rules.html Poker tables Poker tables http://www.nutzu.com/poker-tables.html Poker online Poker online http://www.nutzu.com/poker-online.html Texas hold em rules Texas hold em rules http://www.nutzu.com/texas-hold-em-rules.html Online texas holdem Online texas holdem http://www.nutzu.com/online-texas-holdem.html Three card poker Three card poker http://www.nutzu.com/three-card-poker.html Pai gow poker Pai gow poker http://www.nutzu.com/pai-gow-poker.html Strip poker Strip poker http://www.nutzu.com/strip-poker.html Poker games Poker games http://www.nutzu.com/poker-games.html Rules of poker Rules of poker http://www.nutzu.com/rules-of-poker.html World series of poker World series of poker http://www.nutzu.com/world-series-of-poker.html Free online poker Free online poker http://www.nutzu.com/free-online-poker.html World poker tour World poker tour http://www.nutzu.com/world-poker-tour.html Free texas hold em Free texas hold em http://www.nutzu.com/free-texas-hold-em.html Wsop Wsop http://www.nutzu.com/wsop.html Play poker online Play poker online http://www.nutzu.com/play-poker-online.html Play poker Play poker http://www.nutzu.com/play-poker.html Poker tournaments Poker tournaments http://www.nutzu.com/poker-tournaments.html Poker party Poker party http://www.nutzu.com/poker-party.html Online poker rooms Online poker rooms http://www.nutzu.com/online-poker-rooms.html ...

Posted by: Texas hold`em at February 17, 2005 10:20 PM

Please check the pages in the field of Texas hold em Texas hold em http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-hold-em.html Empire poker Empire poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/empire-poker.html Pacific poker Pacific poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/pacific-poker.html Party poker Party poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/party-poker.html Online poker Online poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/online-poker.html Texas holdem Texas holdem http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-holdem.html Poker Poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker.html Poker Poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/ World poker tour World poker tour http://www.highprofitclub.com/world-poker-tour.html Free online poker Free online poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/free-online-poker.html World series of poker World series of poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/world-series-of-poker.html Rules of poker Rules of poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/rules-of-poker.html Poker games Poker games http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-games.html Strip poker Strip poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/strip-poker.html Video poker Video poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/video-poker.html Pai gow poker Pai gow poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/pai-gow-poker.html Three card poker Three card poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/three-card-poker.html Texas poker Texas poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-poker.html Online texas holdem Online texas holdem http://www.highprofitclub.com/online-texas-holdem.html Texas hold em rules Texas hold em rules http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-hold-em-rules.html Poker online Poker online http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-online.html Free poker Free poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/free-poker.html Poker tables Poker tables http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-tables.html Texas holdem rules Texas holdem rules http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-holdem-rules.html Poker hands Poker hands http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-hands.html Poker rules Poker rules http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-rules.html How to play poker How to play poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/how-to-play-poker.html Poker tournament Poker tournament http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-tournament.html Online poker games Online poker games http://www.highprofitclub.com/online-poker-games.html Poker room Poker room http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-room.html Texas hold em poker Texas hold em poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-hold-em-poker.html Poker game Poker game http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-game.html Internet poker Internet poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/internet-poker.html Free texas hold em Free texas hold em http://www.highprofitclub.com/free-texas-hold-em.html Texas holdem poker Texas holdem poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/texas-holdem-poker.html Wsop Wsop http://www.highprofitclub.com/wsop.html Play poker online Play poker online http://www.highprofitclub.com/play-poker-online.html Play poker Play poker http://www.highprofitclub.com/play-poker.html Poker party Poker party http://www.highprofitclub.com/poker-party.html Online poker rooms Online poker rooms http://www.highprofitclub.com/online-poker-rooms.html ... Thanks!!!

Posted by: Texas hold em at March 2, 2005 02:57 AM

snoring
stop snoring
snoring remedies
how to stop snoring
snoring treatments
cures for snoring
snoring cures
snoring problem
http://snoring.crpublish.com

Posted by: snoring problem at April 24, 2005 11:09 AM

people search
people search
people finder
people finder
free people search
free people finder
free public records
background checks
public records
background check
criminal records
free background checks
free background check
net detective
free criminal background check
criminal background check
absolutely free background checks
free people searches
people finders
people search free
yahoo people search
people searches
tenant screening
employment screening
locate people
free court records
background investigations
free public records search
http://people-search.crpublish.com

Posted by: background investigations at May 2, 2005 10:55 AM

adoption
children
child
baby names
baby
babies
adoption agency
family
international adoption
kidsbirth
http://adoptionbook.pedronetwork.com

Posted by: baby at May 8, 2005 05:12 AM

motivation
sales training
positive thinking
leadership
communication skills
personal development
business plan
sales management training
http://www.tgimondays.com/pmg

Posted by: sales training at May 11, 2005 06:07 PM

used cars
used car prices
used cars online
buy used cars
carsearch
car search
http://carsearch.webshoppingguides.com

Posted by: used car prices at May 24, 2005 02:16 AM

fat burning secrets
how to lose fat
weight loss guide
bodybuilding secrets
natural diet programs
http://fat-burning-secrets.bargainfront.com

Posted by: how to lose fat at June 1, 2005 01:23 AM

fat burning secrets
how to lose fat
weight loss guide
bodybuilding secrets
natural diet programs
http://fat-burning-secrets.bargainfront.com

Posted by: weight loss guide at June 2, 2005 02:35 AM

diet secrets
diet program
fast weight loss
weight loss guide
http://perfect-diet.bargainfront.com

Posted by: diet program at June 2, 2005 09:27 AM

sample job interview questions
job interview tips
job interview
job interviews
job interview questions
http://job-interviews.ocsparkle.com

Posted by: sample job interview questions at June 22, 2005 05:10 AM

free music downloads
music downloads
http://www.myfreemp3s.com

Posted by: free music downloads at July 1, 2005 07:26 PM

government grants
small business grants
grant writing
http://www.grants-unlimited.com

Posted by: grant writing at July 3, 2005 03:25 PM

barbie girl, jigsaw puzzles, wooden toys, doll furniture, rocking horse
http://www.toycity.biz

Posted by: barbie girl, jigsaw puzzles, wooden toys, doll furniture, rocking horse at February 10, 2006 03:05 PM

parent directory
domestic discipline
school discipline powerpoint
child disciplne
http://parent-directory.what-every-parent-needs-to-know.com

Posted by: school discipline powerpoint at February 17, 2006 04:04 PM

parenting advice
parenting tips
parenting teenagers
aprenting skills
http://parenting-advice.what-every-parent-needs-to-know.com

Posted by: parenting tips at February 17, 2006 04:07 PM

teen, teens, juvenile, summer camp, summer camps, troubled teens
http://www.parentshelpingchildren.com

Posted by: teen, teens, juvenile, summer camp, summer camps, troubled teens at February 23, 2006 06:34 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?